After all this time I finally noticed the Tirpitz card has a "start year" of 1942. Tirpitz was commissioned in February, 1941. She was flagship of the Baltic fleet through the rest of 1941.
I can't believe I only just now noticed this. I was working on a tournament scenario and was wondering why Tirpitz didn't show up as an option in Hap's spreadsheet. When I saw the spreadsheet had Tirpitz as 1942 I thought the spreadsheet must have an error. I looked at the WotC are sure enough it says 1942.
I think this is definitely an "errata in waiting."
Am I missing something? I did a quick Forumini search and didn't find any mention of this issue.
The IJN Carrier Liberation Force - "Because We Care" Join the IJNCVLF. Service Guarantees Citizenship!
That could be the reason. The AA score on her is kind of ridiculous and was assumed at the time the card came out to represent her while protected in the fjords.
I think representing a later refit with a later year does more harm than good. Tirpitz is officially unavailable during a year that she actually existed. We will never know if that was actually the reason though.
The IJN Carrier Liberation Force - "Because We Care" Join the IJNCVLF. Service Guarantees Citizenship!
I think RB did that more or less as a "this is when the ship as shown was really operational."
This is the case with quite a lot of other ships, like USS Essex, which launched and commissioned by the very end of 1942, and Yamato, which was commissioned very shortly after the attack on Pearl Harbor, but have a 1943 and 1942 "start years," respectively.
I would call that an "official errata." The ship was commissioned in early 1941 and operational by mid-year so there is no question about it's status in 1941 IMO. RB did the whole game basically by himself so it is really quite amazing that he made so few errors in the first place.
The IJN Carrier Liberation Force - "Because We Care" Join the IJNCVLF. Service Guarantees Citizenship!
So, is everyone good with adding an errata for the Tirpitz to 1941 based on RB's comments? I would add it to the "Forumini" add-on part, not to the original WotC Update and Clarification pages. Just above or below the Installation clarifications.
Comments? Do we need to vote?
The IJN Carrier Liberation Force - "Because We Care" Join the IJNCVLF. Service Guarantees Citizenship!
There are always delays between launching/commissioning/training/shakedown and actual deployment. For example, USS Alabama was launched August 1942, but her first actual deployment was April 1943. Her card gives her a 1942 playing date, which I would rate an errata. The Germans used the Baltic as a safe training setting. Tirpitz's first deployment to Norway was early 1942. I am happy with this date for her card.