Now, I never had a great experience when it came to getting War at Sea booster packs. Looking back at my collection, I could count the total number of battleships I pulled in one hand. I can count the number of 50+ battleships I pulled with two fingers. As for the number of heavy cruisers I pulled... let's just say I could make a whole fleet of exclusively Mogamis. Now, I always thought that I just had plain bad luck (and that may partly be the case), but looking back, I was also quite late into getting booster packs, only starting around 2015, by which time Base Set, Task Force and Set V boosters were all but impossible to get at reasonable prices. (By the way, does anyone know why Set V got so expensive so quickly?) It occurred to me that it'd be rather easy to weigh booster boxes and pick out which ones had the big battleships and carriers, especially given the size difference between heavy cruisers and the big boys. I also purchased all of them online, so it'd be quite easy for more ill-meaning vendors to pick out the lighter ones and send them out. Though, given how niche this game was, the incentive might not be there to do that in the first place. I was curious to hear people's thoughts on this matter.
When it came to buying AAAF boosters, I would squeeze the box. If there was a lot of give, I assumed the usual aircraft. But if it hit resistance right away, then: a Corsair, a Stuka, a Sturmovik .. . something BIG. And I was rarely wrong.
Those who don't remember their history are bound to do something or other...
I never came across a booster weigher, but it seems like everyone had a system for figuring out what booster to buy if you were fishing for something. A dentist posted x-rays of some boosters a while back and you can actually identify the ships inside which was cool. My personal method was to do the shake test to hear whether something big was inside but that was maybe 75% accurate at best.
I think I weighed a heavy booster box and a light booster box at some point to see what the variance was and it was small. Even with a postal scale you only have accuracy to a tenth of an ounce. There are also some heavyish pieces that aren’t particularly valuable and light ones that are very much so. In Surface Action a Corsair, Edsall, Algonquin, American Victory, Wasp booster is one of the lightest configurations but also one of the most valuable pulls, and that’s just one example.
I used the "shake test" occassionally as well. I think it was the most reliable if you were looking for a big rare. For anything else it was pretty much impossible to tell.
Some retail stores put the boosters behind the counter to prevent people from shaking or weighing them.
The absolute best way to avoid getting a lot of repeats was to buy an entire case. Particularly with Sets III to VI you would pretty reliably get everything except four of the rares. WotC was pretty good about that.
The IJN Carrier Liberation Force - "Because We Care" Join the IJNCVLF. Service Guarantees Citizenship!
In the good old days when base set boosters boxes were huge the shake test helped, but wasn’t fool proof. The shake test was far more accurate when the packaging got smaller.
A few years ago I got the chance to buy 23 unopened booster cases from every set but the base set. I too wanted to see if there was a weight predictability. I used a food scale to weight each case and found some were much heavier then others. Upon opening them and weighing the boosters individually the heaviest included large rares with all boats. In comparison, the lightest boosters had small rares with planes. The differences in weight were by a .1 of a gram. But from big to small it was by a few grams. In short the only predictability was for something really big or really small.
Yeah. I’m pretty much done trying to chase booster packs. Too easy to weed through the packs. Unless you’re missing some rare cruisers you’re probably going to be dissatisfied with your packs.