I am curious as to how the ranges are calculated for the various guns. Particularly how they arrived at their numbers for the units with extended ranges. I apologize if this question seems silly; but, I have only started getting interested in the game over the last year or so.
I am curious as to how the ranges are calculated for the various guns. Particularly how they arrived at their numbers for the units with extended ranges. I apologize if this question seems silly; but, I have only started getting interested in the game over the last year or so.
Thanks for your assistance.
Although we did at one time have a WotC staffer who posted on the old Forumini the forumlas were never disclosed for any calcs regarding the cards. Some stuff we did figure out but range value formulas are only subject to speculation and guesses. Sorry I couldn't be too much help.
When you go home, tell them of us and say, For your tomorrows these gave their today. ~J.M. Edmonds
I'm sure it has to do with distance. One of the other variables is likely accuracy. German guns had superior accuracy and hitting power so they got range 10 & 12. The British 17 pounders had hitting power and penetration but weren't accurate beyond 1000m so they only got range 8. German superior optics were also an advantage to axis forces and likely translated into better values in AAM.
When you go home, tell them of us and say, For your tomorrows these gave their today. ~J.M. Edmonds
I had wondered if accuracy was a factor in calculating ranges. I was not sure if it was a factor in gun ranges or in how they arrived at the number of dice rolled. After all just because a gun could fire long ranges it did not always mean they were effective at those distances. Although I imagine it might be a in both. Also I had wondered about the optics; because even if a Jagdpanther could shoot over a kilometer; what were the chances it could see a T-34/85 at that distance?
...... Also I had wondered about the optics; because even if a Jagdpanther could shoot over a kilometer; what were the chances it could see a T-34/85 at that distance?
Germany had very high quality optical periscopes during the WWII area. But another factor would be training and combat experience. In the early and middle part of the war, Germany had better artillery and tank crews. By the time you got to the late war period, many of these experienced soldiers had died and were replaced by soldiers with little training or experience. So even though they had better tanks and guns, they didn't use them as well. From the mid to late war period, Allied soldiers on both the Eastern and Western fronts got better training and combat experience. So they performed much better compared to the early war period. So you can have great equipment, but if you don't know how to use it, it won't give you as good results.
I have pondered this for hours, days, weeks... and I have no clear answer. The thing to focus on (Ive been working on this) is to make the guns the same. I could never figure out why a German 105 is different from an American 105. If one can shoot 16 hexes, then both can.