Two notes: 1) A ship can either make ASW attacks or surface attacks (it blew my mind when I found out too), I'll count the surface attack since that actually did something; and 2) There is no penalty against ships that start the phase damaged, so you got one extra hit on Wichita which was sunk anyways.
Wow. I don't know what it is but apparently my battleships really like vitalling your battleships. Moving on... Houston MG @ Gorizia-2 RT12VamD6d6-1 Houston 2nd @ Luca 4d6 -16d6·4d6