Ok, so I hate to do this because it is so not fair, but I believe the PBY gets through now because of the re-roll. Only two points were scored against it on the re-roll.
If there’s a controversy, we can wait for mnnorthstars to decide, but the PBY will use shadow which aids the next two attacks, so we should hold for a judgement if we are unsure.
The Escort SA on the Wildcat subtracts 1 from each die rolled against the PBY so you would have rolled a 5 and a 4 against it for 2 points. I’m a noob for sure, so if I have that wrong, let me know.
I think the way escort works is that you only hit on 5s and 6s, so it’s three? We should definitely wait for mnnorthstars because if I’m wrong I’ve totally been doing that wrong for a while.
I think I am just as likely (probably more) to be wrong as you are. It’s set up such that two different people could be calculating it differently and not necessarily run into a conflict. We should go to bed anyway lol.