Last post as I finish up a third cup of coffee. I really don't want to come off as overly critical. Just wanted to give you the feedback you were looking for. My only other comment is that there are a number of units with no SAs. Not sure if that's a deliberate choice (blank cards used to be a thing, but they are rarely seen now), or if you're looking for suggestions on those cards. If the later, happy to help in offering up stuff.
All that being said, there are several awesome cards here. In particular, these really caught my eye:
I appreciate all the comments. That’s the input I was looking for, as well as if some stats may be off. The whole point is that a lot of these are new classes of ships and so I had to guess on some of the outfits.
Campbeltown I think you’re right. I was trying to be clever and succinct with the wording but if it got past you guys then I need to clarify.
When this unit invades an Installation...
But the carrot for using her is the disguise. She’s hard to stop but if you get close you can’t just knock on the door indefinitely. This was a floating bomb!
Maury Shore Support is down to being a house rule thing where you use it for scenarios and “any island on the opponent’s side.” In this set there’s room for those kinds of cards. Lots of destroyers bombarded targets and this is a nod to that service, which is why I wanted that SA somewhere in the set.
Ford I hadn’t considered the ANB. But I don’t think it’s too overpowering (nor the best use of the points) to put this ship that far forward. You’d have to win initiative to make the torpedoes/weak ASW count. As a side note, has anyone played Battlestations: Midway? That ship is (and was) all over the place!
Porter Playing devil’s advocate, it’s a very cheap AA6? If you don’t gun and don’t torpedo, it’s a steal. Maybe send it on ASW duty.
Making the cards I am not a graphic artist. The silhouettes are all Sackville. The Allied cards are all based on Canberra and the Axis cards are all based on Duca d’Aosta. The “image” to the right of the stats is what’s left of those cards’ images. I would like to put a picture of the destroyer in there, but I didn’t want to put a picture in there more than I wanted to put these cards out. So yeah, I would like to have something better in that space. These are made on Paint, actually I copied and pasted letters from other cards to make the ship names and copied some other ships’ stat tables. The font you see except for the SAs is the same as on the sets 1-4 cards. On the SA text I wound up being all over the place, but it’s a pain to try to redo them. I probably will delete the spaces. I do like how they make for a cleaner look when it all does fit.
Again, thanks for the insight! What else have you got?
All that being said, there are several awesome cards here. In particular, these really caught my eye: ... These are all genuinely awesome. Bravo my friend!
I’m glad you like them. I have some favorites too!
Northstars, I absolutely love this idea and I for one applaud the use of ships with no SA's. With forum expansions, etc the game & history certainly has enough room for a couple of "plain janes" for each nation. The lack of SAs is almost an SA in itself in a way.
Northstars, I absolutely love this idea and I for one applaud the use of ships with no SA's. With forum expansions, etc the game & history certainly has enough room for a couple of "plain janes" for each nation. The lack of SAs is almost an SA in itself in a way.
More thoughts later - need copious coffee.
Glad you like the concept. I’ll be interested to know your in-depth thoughts. Sounds like you guys run on coffee.
Northstars, I absolutely love this idea and I for one applaud the use of ships with no SA's. With forum expansions, etc the game & history certainly has enough room for a couple of "plain janes" for each nation. The lack of SAs is almost an SA in itself in a way.
More thoughts later - need copious coffee.
Glad you like the concept. I’ll be interested to know your in-depth thoughts. Sounds like you guys run on coffee.
They should be bigger images on the website. The content is the same, I just clicked thumbnails instead of direct link when I ported the links over, and then the flavor text is commingled, and I don’t have time to merge the larger images with the text.